diff --git a/.gitattributes b/.gitattributes index 6b79dca..c9de670 100644 --- a/.gitattributes +++ b/.gitattributes @@ -4,3 +4,4 @@ tests/fixtures/objective_coverage/** -text *.pdf binary docs/findings/rrb-01/precheck-2b/** -text docs/findings/rrb-01/precheck-2b/** -text +docs/findings/rrb-01/extraction/** -text diff --git a/docs/findings/rrb-01/extraction/founder_extraction.jsonl b/docs/findings/rrb-01/extraction/founder_extraction.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000..06fc124 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/findings/rrb-01/extraction/founder_extraction.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,59 @@ +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-1-1","source":"HWA17","location":"p.1, Abstract, paragraph 1","evidence":"LiNi1-x-yMnxAlyO2 promises a completely cobalt-free composition with almost the same electrochemical performance as that of the conventional high-nickel cathode.","cited_primary_study":"none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"LiNi1-x-yMnxAlyO2","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"promises a completely cobalt-free composition","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-2-1","source":"HWA17","location":"p.2, Section 1, paragraph 1","evidence":"Replacing Co with Ni is one of the most reasonable choices.","cited_primary_study":"none","parent_as_published":"LiCoO2","target_as_published":"LiNiO2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_integer"},"direction_basis":"Replacing Co with Ni","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-2-2","source":"HWA17","location":"p.2, Section 1, paragraph 1","evidence":"Other elements, such as Al and Mg, have also been shown to be good candidates for replacing Co [8,9].","cited_primary_study":"[8,9] none","parent_as_published":"LiCoO2","target_as_published":"Al","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"family_no_composition"},"direction_basis":"replacing Co","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-3-1","source":"HWA17","location":"p.3, Section 2, paragraph 1","evidence":"The addition of Co for the partial substitution of Ni in the NMC cathode is beneficial for obtaining facile electron transfers.","cited_primary_study":"[23-25] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"Co","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"partial substitution of Ni","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-3-2","source":"HWA17","location":"p.3, Section 2, paragraph 1","evidence":"NMC111 was replaced by NMC622 LiNi0.6Mn0.2Co0.2O2 and NMC811 LiNi0.8Mn0.1Co0.1O2 [29].","cited_primary_study":"[29] none","parent_as_published":"LiNi1/3Mn1/3Co1/3O2","target_as_published":"LiNi0.6Mn0.2Co0.2O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"was replaced by","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-3-3","source":"HWA17","location":"p.3, Section 2, paragraph 1","evidence":"NMC111 was replaced by NMC622 LiNi0.6Mn0.2Co0.2O2 and NMC811 LiNi0.8Mn0.1Co0.1O2 [29].","cited_primary_study":"[29] none","parent_as_published":"LiNi1/3Mn1/3Co1/3O2","target_as_published":"LiNi0.8Mn0.1Co0.1O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"was replaced by","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-4-1","source":"HWA17","location":"p.4, Section 2, paragraph 2","evidence":"Li et al. ... systematically studying various compositions of cobalt replacement cations in the LiNi1-xMxO2 composition (M = Al, Co, Mg, or Mn; x = 0.05 or 0.1).","cited_primary_study":"[8] none","parent_as_published":"LiNiO2","target_as_published":"LiNi1-xMxO2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"cobalt replacement cations","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-4-2","source":"HWA17","location":"p.4, Section 2, paragraph 2","evidence":"LiNi0.95Mg0.05O2 yielded a lower initial discharge capacity of 205 mAh g-1 when compared to LiNi0.95Mn0.05O2 of 219 mAh g-1.","cited_primary_study":"[8] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"LiNi0.95Mg0.05O2","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"when compared to","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-4-3","source":"HWA17","location":"p.4, Section 2, paragraph 2","evidence":"LiNi0.95Al0.05O2 are similar to that of NCA.","cited_primary_study":"[8] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"NCA","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"family_no_composition"},"direction_basis":"similar to that of NCA","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-5-1","source":"HWA17","location":"p.5, Section 2, paragraph 1","evidence":"cobalt substitution (LiNi0.95Co0.05O2) does not improve the thermal stability compared to LiNi0.95Mg0.05O2, LiNi0.95Al0.05O2, and LiNi0.95Mn0.05O2.","cited_primary_study":"[8] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"LiNi0.95Co0.05O2","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"compared to","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-5-2","source":"HWA17","location":"p.5, Section 2, paragraph 2","evidence":"The volume changes in NMC811 are more significant than those of LiNi1/3Mn1/3Co1/3O2 (NMC111).","cited_primary_study":"[38] none","parent_as_published":"LiNi1/3Mn1/3Co1/3O2","target_as_published":"LiNi0.8Mn0.1Co0.1O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"more significant than","relationship_type":null,"characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"not_directed","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-6-1","source":"HWA17","location":"p.6, Section 3.1, paragraph 1","evidence":"Various types of cations have been studied as alternatives to cobalt in Ni-rich cathodes.","cited_primary_study":"[48-50] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"Mg2+","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"alternatives to cobalt","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-6-2","source":"HWA17","location":"p.6, Section 3.1, paragraph 2","evidence":"thermal stability could be improved in LiNixM1-xO2 by substituting the dopant Mn, Mg, Al, or Co in which x = 0 or 0.05.","cited_primary_study":"[51] none","parent_as_published":"LiNiO2","target_as_published":"LiNixM1-xO2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"substituting the dopant Mn, Mg, Al, or Co","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-7-1","source":"HWA17","location":"p.7, Section 3.1, paragraph 2","evidence":"the effect of Mn dopant on the electrochemical performance of LiNi0.9Mn0.1O2, which is the development of the most studied cobalt-free nickel-rich cathode material, LiNi0.5Mn0.5O2.","cited_primary_study":"[55] none","parent_as_published":"LiNi0.5Mn0.5O2","target_as_published":"LiNi0.9Mn0.1O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"is the development of","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"ambiguous","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":"is the development of implies lineage but does not explicitly state a parent-to-target substitution direction under the locked rules.","parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-7-2","source":"HWA17","location":"p.7, Section 3.1, paragraph 2","evidence":"the fracture strength of the LiNi0.9Mn0.1O2 particles was 25% higher than that to LiNi0.9Mn0.05Co0.05O2 (140 MPa).","cited_primary_study":"[55] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"LiNi0.9Mn0.1O2","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"higher than","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-7-3","source":"HWA17","location":"p.7, Section 3.1, paragraph 2","evidence":"Among Mn, Mg, Al, or Co-doped LNO materials, Li[Ni0.9Co0.1]O2 delivers the highest specific discharge capacity of 233 mAh g-1.","cited_primary_study":"[59] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"Li[Ni0.9Co0.1]O2","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"Among ... doped LNO materials","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-7-4","source":"HWA17","location":"p.7, Section 3.2, paragraph 1","evidence":"improve the electrochemical performance of the cathode material of high-nickel composition LiNi1-xMxO2 (M = Mn, Al, and/or Co).","cited_primary_study":"[51,55,60] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"LiNi1-xMxO2","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"high-nickel composition LiNi1-xMxO2","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-9-1","source":"HWA17","location":"p.9, Section 3.2, paragraph 2","evidence":"the LiNiO2 core with the LiNi0.83Mg0.17O2 shell is capable of providing an initial discharge capacity of 194 mAh g-1.","cited_primary_study":"[76-78] none","parent_as_published":"LiNiO2","target_as_published":"LiNi0.83Mg0.17O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"core with ... shell","relationship_type":null,"characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":["morphology_change"],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"morphology_or_surface_only","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-9-2","source":"HWA17","location":"p.9, Section 3.2, paragraph 2","evidence":"230 mAh g-1 for the LiNi0.83Al0.17O2 shell.","cited_primary_study":"[76-78] none","parent_as_published":"LiNiO2","target_as_published":"LiNi0.83Al0.17O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"shell","relationship_type":null,"characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":["morphology_change"],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"morphology_or_surface_only","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-9-3","source":"HWA17","location":"p.9, Section 3.2, paragraph 2","evidence":"Li-Ni0.83Mn0.17O2 shell.","cited_primary_study":"[76-78] none","parent_as_published":"LiNiO2","target_as_published":"LiNi0.83Mn0.17O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"shell","relationship_type":null,"characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":["morphology_change"],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"morphology_or_surface_only","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-10-1","source":"HWA17","location":"p.10, Section 3.2, paragraph 5","evidence":"LiNi0.883Mn0.056Al0.061O2 (NMA-89) has a comparable specific discharge capacity of 216 mAh g-1 with LiNi0.890Mn0.055Co0.055O2 (NMC-89).","cited_primary_study":"[96] none","parent_as_published":"NMC-89","target_as_published":"LiNi0.883Mn0.056Al0.061O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"comparable ... with","relationship_type":"cross_chemistry_analog","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"ambiguous","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":"Sentence states \"comparable with\"; broader passage calls NMA a cobalt-free alternative to NMC/NCA, but the locked rules do not resolve whether this is a directed replacement.","parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-10-2","source":"HWA17","location":"p.10, Section 3.2, paragraph 5","evidence":"a new type of material for cobalt-free high-nickel cathodes, namely LiNi1-x-yMnxAlyO2 (NMA), which has been synthesized successfully with overall superior electrochemical performance compared to NMC and NCA.","cited_primary_study":"[96] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"LiNi1-x-yMnxAlyO2","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"compared to NMC and NCA","relationship_type":"cross_chemistry_analog","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-11-1","source":"HWA17","location":"p.11, Section 3.2, paragraph 6","evidence":"NMA with various compositions, namely, LiNi0.80Mn0.13Al0.07O2 can be engineered to meet various electrochemical performance targets.","cited_primary_study":"[96] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"LiNi0.80Mn0.13Al0.07O2","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"can be engineered to meet various electrochemical performance targets","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-11-2","source":"HWA17","location":"p.11, Section 4, paragraph 1","evidence":"partial substitution of Co atoms with Mn, Al, and Mg atoms improves thermal stability and cycle stability.","cited_primary_study":"none","parent_as_published":"Co","target_as_published":"Mn","composition_type":{"parent":"family_no_composition","target":"family_no_composition"},"direction_basis":"partial substitution of Co atoms with Mn, Al, and Mg atoms","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"HWA17-11-3","source":"HWA17","location":"p.11, Section 4, paragraph 1","evidence":"Mn doping on LiNiO2 does not affect the initial discharge capacity but results in an increased degree of mixing of Ni2+/Li+ cations.","cited_primary_study":"none","parent_as_published":"LiNiO2","target_as_published":"Mn","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"family_no_composition"},"direction_basis":"Mn doping on LiNiO2","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-6-1","source":"NOE21","location":"p.6, Section 1.1, paragraph 1","evidence":"The O3 type layers, alpha beta and gamma-type LiFeO2, have advantages ... However, de-intercalation does not occur in Li cells.","cited_primary_study":"[34-38] none","parent_as_published":"LiFeO2","target_as_published":"NaFeO2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_integer"},"direction_basis":"isostructural analog","relationship_type":"cross_chemistry_analog","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-6-2","source":"NOE21","location":"p.6, Section 1.1, paragraph 1","evidence":"Matsumura et al. suggested that Li2/3[Mn1/3Fe2/3]O2 ... ionic exchange from Na2/3[Mn1/3Fe2/3]O2","cited_primary_study":"[41] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3[Mn1/3Fe2/3]O2","target_as_published":"Li2/3[Mn1/3Fe2/3]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"ionic exchange from","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"not_directed","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-6-3","source":"NOE21","location":"p.6, Section 1.1, paragraph 2","evidence":"This detrimental effect is suppressed by Mn in Na[Fe0.5Mn0.5]O2, which exhibits a reversible capacity of approximately 100 mAh g-1.","cited_primary_study":"[46] none","parent_as_published":"NaFeO2","target_as_published":"Na[Fe0.5Mn0.5]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"suppressed by Mn","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-6-4","source":"NOE21","location":"p.6, Section 1.1, paragraph 3","evidence":"Partial substitution of Fe sites by Co is interesting ... NaFe0.5Co0.5O2.","cited_primary_study":"[47] none","parent_as_published":"NaFeO2","target_as_published":"NaFe0.5Co0.5O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"Partial substitution of Fe sites by Co","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-7-1","source":"NOE21","location":"p.7, Section 1.1, paragraph 1","evidence":"Wang et al. stabilized the crystal structure of NaFeO2 by forming a solid solution with NaNiO2, NaFe1-xNixO2 (0<=x<=1).","cited_primary_study":"[48] none","parent_as_published":"NaFeO2","target_as_published":"NaFe1-xNixO2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"forming a solid solution with NaNiO2","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-7-2","source":"NOE21","location":"p.7, Section 1.1, paragraph 1","evidence":"The dilution of the Fe concentration, NaFe0.3Ni0.7O2, effectively increased capacity and retention (135 mA h g-1 and 74% retention after 30 cycles).","cited_primary_study":"[48] none","parent_as_published":"NaFeO2","target_as_published":"NaFe0.3Ni0.7O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"dilution of the Fe concentration","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-7-3","source":"NOE21","location":"p.7, Section 1.1, paragraph 2","evidence":"Extension of the layer structure toward a three component system, Na[Ni1/3Fe1/3Mn1/3]O2, was suggested by Kim et al.","cited_primary_study":"[50] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"Na[Ni1/3Fe1/3Mn1/3]O2","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"Extension of the layer structure toward a three component system","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-7-4","source":"NOE21","location":"p.7, Section 1.1, paragraph 3","evidence":"Oh et al. suggested another approach to raise the upper voltage cutoff to 4.4 V ... reducing the concentration of Fe3+ in Na[Li0.05(Ni0.25Fe0.25Mn0.5)0.95]O2.","cited_primary_study":"[52] none","parent_as_published":"Na[Ni0.25Fe0.5Mn0.25]O2","target_as_published":"Na[Li0.05(Ni0.25Fe0.25Mn0.5)0.95]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"reducing the concentration of Fe3+","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-7-5","source":"NOE21","location":"p.7, Section 1.2, paragraph 2","evidence":"Partial substitution of Fe by Mn made it possible to utilize the electrochemical oxidization of Fe3+ to Fe4+ reversibly ... P2-Nax[Fe0.5Mn0.5]O2 layer compound.","cited_primary_study":"[46] none","parent_as_published":"Na[Fe0.5Mn0.5]O2","target_as_published":"P2-Nax[Fe0.5Mn0.5]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"Partial substitution of Fe by Mn","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-9-1","source":"NOE21","location":"p.9, Section 1.2, paragraph 1","evidence":"Jung et al. explored the effects of Co on P2-Na0.7[(Fe0.5Mn0.5)1-xCox]O2 (x = 0 - 0.2). ... the addition of Co into the transition metal layers ... resulted in higher capacity","cited_primary_study":"[58] none","parent_as_published":"Na0.7[(Fe0.5Mn0.5)1-xCox]O2 (x=0)","target_as_published":"Na0.7[(Fe0.5Mn0.5)0.8Co0.2]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"unresolved_variable","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"addition of Co into the transition metal layers","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-9-2","source":"NOE21","location":"p.9, Section 1.2, paragraph 1","evidence":"Jung et al. explored the effects of Co on P2-Na0.7[(Fe0.5Mn0.5)1-xCox]O2 (x = 0 - 0.2).","cited_primary_study":"[58] none","parent_as_published":"Na0.7[(Fe0.5Mn0.5)1-xCox]O2","target_as_published":"Na0.7[(Fe0.5Mn0.5)1-xCox]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"unresolved_variable","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"effects of Co on P2-Na0.7[(Fe0.5Mn0.5)1-xCox]O2","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-9-3","source":"NOE21","location":"p.9, Section 1.2, paragraph 3","evidence":"Ni-doping of the transition metal sites in Nax[Fe0.5Mn0.5]O2 is less prone to react in air.","cited_primary_study":"[61] none","parent_as_published":"Nax[Fe0.5Mn0.5]O2","target_as_published":"Ni-doped Nax[Fe0.5Mn0.5]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"Ni-doping of the transition metal sites","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-10-1","source":"NOE21","location":"p.10, Section 1.4, paragraph 1","evidence":"Carlier et al. evaluated P2-Na2/3[Co2/3Mn1/3]O2 ... Yang et al. extended the stability of P2-Na2/3[Co1-xMnx]O2 to x = 0.5.","cited_primary_study":"[76,77] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3[Co2/3Mn1/3]O2","target_as_published":"Na2/3[Co0.5Mn0.5]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"extended the stability ... to x = 0.5","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-10-2","source":"NOE21","location":"p.10, Section 1.4, paragraph 1","evidence":"The main difference after Mn substitution for Co is abrupt voltage decay in a range of 0.65<=x<=0.83 in Nae[Co2/3Mn1/3]O2.","cited_primary_study":"[76] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3CoO2","target_as_published":"Na2/3[Co2/3Mn1/3]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"Mn substitution for Co","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"not_directed","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-12-1","source":"NOE21","location":"p.12, Section 1.4, paragraph 3","evidence":"Matsui et al. explored the possibility of Ca-doping at Na sites to form Na2/3-xCaxCoO2.","cited_primary_study":"[79] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3CoO2","target_as_published":"Na2/3-xCaxCoO2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"Ca-doping at Na sites","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-12-2","source":"NOE21","location":"p.12, Section 1.4, paragraph 3","evidence":"The similarity in the ionic radius of Ca2+ (1.00 A) versus Na+ (1.02 A) allows the incorporation of Ca2+ into the Na sites.","cited_primary_study":"[79] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3CoO2","target_as_published":"Na2/3-xCaxCoO2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"incorporation of Ca2+ into the Na sites","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-12-3","source":"NOE21","location":"p.12, Section 1.5, paragraph 2","evidence":"Komaba et al. applied the findings of research on Li[Ni0.5Mn0.5]O2 to Na[Ni0.5Mn0.5]O2, in which the average oxidation states of Ni and Mn are 2+ and 4+ respectively.","cited_primary_study":"[83] none","parent_as_published":"Li[Ni0.5Mn0.5]O2","target_as_published":"Na[Ni0.5Mn0.5]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"applied the findings of research on ... to","relationship_type":"cross_chemistry_analog","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-12-4","source":"NOE21","location":"p.12, Section 1.5, paragraph 2","evidence":"Fe-substituted Na[Ni0.5Mn0.5]O2, however, underwent different structural transformation during desodiation compared with Na[Ni0.5Mn0.5]O2.","cited_primary_study":"[84] none","parent_as_published":"Na[Ni0.5Mn0.5]O2","target_as_published":"Fe-substituted Na[Ni0.5Mn0.5]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"Fe-substituted","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-12-5","source":"NOE21","location":"p.12, Section 1.5, paragraph 2","evidence":"Hwang et al. investigated the collation of Ni and Fe contents in Na[Ni0.75-xFexMn0.25]O2 (x = 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, and 0.55).","cited_primary_study":"[85] none","parent_as_published":"Na[Ni0.75-xFexMn0.25]O2","target_as_published":"Na[Ni0.75-xFexMn0.25]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"unresolved_variable","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"collation of Ni and Fe contents","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-12-6","source":"NOE21","location":"p.12, Section 1.5, paragraph 3","evidence":"They also developed a radially-aligned hierarchical columnar structure ... from the inner end (Na[Ni0.75Co0.02Mn0.23]O2) to the outer end (Na[Ni0.58Co0.60Mn0.36]O2).","cited_primary_study":"[87] none","parent_as_published":"Na[Ni0.75Co0.02Mn0.23]O2","target_as_published":"Na[Ni0.58Co0.60Mn0.36]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"varied chemical composition from the inner end ... to the outer end","relationship_type":null,"characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":["spatially_heterogeneous"],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"spatially_heterogeneous","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-12-7","source":"NOE21","location":"p.12, Section 1.5, paragraph 4","evidence":"Ti-Substituted O3-Na[Ni0.5Ti0.5]O2 is also interesting due to its superior cyclability under moderate conditions, with an average operating potential of 3.1 V.","cited_primary_study":"[88] none","parent_as_published":"Na[Ni0.5Mn0.5]O2","target_as_published":"Na[Ni0.5Ti0.5]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"Ti-Substituted O3-Na[Ni0.5Ti0.5]O2","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-14-1","source":"NOE21","location":"p.14, Section 1.6, paragraph 1","evidence":"alpha-NaMnO2 (space group: C2/m) is the low-temperature form and beta-NaMnO2 (space group: Pmnm) is the high-temperature form.","cited_primary_study":"[89,91] none","parent_as_published":"alpha-NaMnO2","target_as_published":"beta-NaMnO2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_integer"},"direction_basis":"low-temperature form / high-temperature form","relationship_type":null,"characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"not_directed","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-14-2","source":"NOE21","location":"p.14, Section 1.6, paragraph 4","evidence":"Surprisingly, Li substitution in the transition metal layer, Na0.80[Li0.12Ni0.22Mn0.66]O2 inhibited P2-O2 transition up to 4.4 V.","cited_primary_study":"[105] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3[Ni1/3Mn2/3]O2","target_as_published":"Na0.80[Li0.12Ni0.22Mn0.66]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"Li substitution in the transition metal layer","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-16-1","source":"NOE21","location":"p.16, Section 1.6, paragraph 5","evidence":"Substitution of divalent elements such as Mg2+ and Zn2+ in Ni is effective for diluting the effect of the above-mentioned P2-O2 phase transition.","cited_primary_study":"[106-113] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3[Ni1/3Mn2/3]O2","target_as_published":"Na0.67[Ni0.2Mg0.1Mn0.7]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"Substitution of divalent elements such as Mg2+ ... in Ni","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-16-2","source":"NOE21","location":"p.16, Section 1.6, paragraph 5","evidence":"Zn-substituted P2-Na2/3[Ni1/3-xZnxMn2/3]O2 induces reversible phase transition during electrochemical reactions.","cited_primary_study":"[111,112] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3[Ni1/3Mn2/3]O2","target_as_published":"Na2/3[Ni1/3-xZnxMn2/3]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"Zn-substituted","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-16-3","source":"NOE21","location":"p.16, Section 1.6, paragraph 5","evidence":"Further studies explored partial replacement of Ni sites by Al.","cited_primary_study":"[113] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3[Ni1/3Mn2/3]O2","target_as_published":"Al-doped P2-Na2/3[Ni1/3Mn2/3]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"partial replacement of Ni sites by Al","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-16-4","source":"NOE21","location":"p.16, Section 1.6, paragraph 6","evidence":"Yoshida et al. investigated the composition of P2-Na0.7[Mn0.6Ni0.3Co0.1]O2 in which the oxidation state of Mn is approximately 3.4+, in a voltage range of 1.5-4.3 V.","cited_primary_study":"[114] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3[Ni1/3Mn2/3]O2","target_as_published":"Na0.7[Mn0.6Ni0.3Co0.1]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"Replacement with a trivalent 3d transition metal element such as Co","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-16-5","source":"NOE21","location":"p.16, Section 1.6, paragraph 7","evidence":"Yuan et al. suggested that Ni substitution with Fe (P2-Na0.7[Mn0.65Ni0.15Fe0.2]O2) led to an improvement in capacity and retention: 208 mAh g-1 with 71% retention over 50 cycles.","cited_primary_study":"[115] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3[Ni1/3Mn2/3]O2","target_as_published":"Na0.7[Mn0.65Ni0.15Fe0.2]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"Ni substitution with Fe","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-16-6","source":"NOE21","location":"p.16, Section 1.6, paragraph 8","evidence":"Tetravalent Ti-substituted P2-Na2/3[Ni1/3Mn2/3-xTix]O2 yielded a wide solid solution range of 0<=x<=2/3.","cited_primary_study":"[118,119] none","parent_as_published":"Na2/3[Ni1/3Mn2/3]O2","target_as_published":"Na2/3[Ni1/3Mn2/3-xTix]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_fractional","target":"unresolved_variable"},"direction_basis":"Tetravalent Ti-substituted","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"unresolved_variable","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-16-7","source":"NOE21","location":"p.16, Section 1.6, paragraph 9","evidence":"A new mechanism was introduced in P2-Na2/3[Mg0.28Mn0.72]O2 and P2-Na5/6[Li1/4Mn3/4]O2 by Yabuuchi and Komaba et al.","cited_primary_study":"[120,121] none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"P2-Na2/3[Mg0.28Mn0.72]O2","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"A new mechanism was introduced in ... and ...","relationship_type":null,"characterization":null,"confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-18-1","source":"NOE21","location":"p.18, Section 1.7, paragraph 1","evidence":"When a solid solution is formed with NaNO2 [Na[Ni0.5Ti0.5]O2] as suggested above by Yu et al., the material is sufficiently stable for long-term cycling as a cathode.","cited_primary_study":"[88] none","parent_as_published":"NaTiO2","target_as_published":"Na[Ni0.5Ti0.5]O2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_fractional"},"direction_basis":"solid solution ... Na[Ni0.5Ti0.5]O2","relationship_type":"within_family_substitution","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"include","exclusion_reason":null,"ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-18-2","source":"NOE21","location":"p.18, Section 1.8, paragraph 1","evidence":"In contrast to LiCrO2 in Li cells, NaCrO2 could deliver a capacity of approximately 110 mAh g-1 in the voltage range of 2-3.6 V.","cited_primary_study":"[128] none","parent_as_published":"LiCrO2","target_as_published":"NaCrO2","composition_type":{"parent":"fixed_integer","target":"fixed_integer"},"direction_basis":"In contrast to LiCrO2 in Li cells","relationship_type":"cross_chemistry_analog","characterization":"experimentally_evaluated_substitute","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"not_directed","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-19-1","source":"NOE21","location":"p.19, Section 1.10, paragraph 1","evidence":"The Na2MO3 (M: metal) layer structure, an analogue of Li2MO3, has alternative layers in a cubic close-packed oxygen array.","cited_primary_study":"none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"Na2MO3","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"family_no_composition"},"direction_basis":"an analogue of Li2MO3","relationship_type":"cross_chemistry_analog","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} +{"schema_version":"rrb01-extract-1","extractor":"founder","record_id":"NOE21-19-2","source":"NOE21","location":"p.19, Section 1.10, paragraph 1","evidence":"Na2RuO3 shows metallic conduction and is crystallized in layer structures consisting of Na and Na1/3Ru2/3 slabs.","cited_primary_study":"none","parent_as_published":null,"target_as_published":"Na2RuO3","composition_type":{"parent":null,"target":"family_no_composition"},"direction_basis":"an analogue of Li2MO3","relationship_type":"cross_chemistry_analog","characterization":"proposed_replacement","confounders":[],"decision":"exclude","exclusion_reason":"no_named_parent","ambiguity_note":null,"parent_normalized":null,"target_normalized":null} diff --git a/docs/findings/rrb-01/extraction/founder_extraction.jsonl.report.json b/docs/findings/rrb-01/extraction/founder_extraction.jsonl.report.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..74d704c --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/findings/rrb-01/extraction/founder_extraction.jsonl.report.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "rrb01-extract-1", + "extractor": "founder", + "input_xlsx": "founder_extraction.xlsx", + "input_xlsx_sha256": "E6CB8B7ADDCBCF7E1F4879DF3A83B6C470AFFD621A6912AF5D5F8DDA41AA525C", + "output_jsonl": "founder_extraction.jsonl", + "output_jsonl_sha256": "7BDB4C2D13DC492A4AE7999EB3547BB2FA41CB9E0BCA665329A5B350E18FF9FC", + "record_count": 59, + "decision_counts": { + "ambiguous": 2, + "exclude": 39, + "include": 18 + }, + "source_counts": { + "HWA17": 25, + "NOE21": 34 + } +} diff --git a/docs/findings/rrb-01/extraction/founder_extraction.xlsx b/docs/findings/rrb-01/extraction/founder_extraction.xlsx new file mode 100644 index 0000000..18d62a2 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/findings/rrb-01/extraction/founder_extraction.xlsx differ